Bug #5233

Remote component search messes up returns which have the same karFileName in kar xml

Added by Jing Tao over 10 years ago. Updated over 10 years ago.

Target version:
Start date:
Due date:
% Done:


Estimated time:


On 2010-09-01, Jones uploaded the kar xml 2099.22.1 and kar file 2099.21.1. In the kar xml, it says the kar file (2099.21.1) NOT having a report module. We looked the kar file, it is true that it doesn't have a report module.

On 2010-10-27, Jones uploaded the kar xml 3075.20. 1 and kar file 2099.21.2. In the kar xml, it says the kar file (2099.21.2) having a report module. We looked the kar file, it is true that it dose have a report module.

Both kar xml have the same karFileName - BoxPlotDemo.kar

However, when we searched the remote repository, it seems there is only one workflow with the name BoxPlotDemo.kar showing - 3075.20.1 with the report. Something is messed up.

I looked the log and saw both "Parsing KAR XML: 2099.22.1" and "Parsing KAR XML: 3075.20.1". This means that metacat's return is good. But kepler component search has a bug. The worse case is that the component search messes up the kar id - it assigns 2099.21.1 which doesn't have a report to kar xml 3075.20. 1. So our workflow run engine downloaded a wrong kar file and executed it. Since the kar file doesn't have a report, there will not be workflow run kar being uploaded to the remote server.


#1 Updated by ben leinfelder over 10 years ago

What server are these on? I can't see them on

#2 Updated by Jing Tao over 10 years ago

I dug around and found in method EcogridRepositoryLibrary.createKarLevel():
it used the kar file name as the entity name to create an entity. When a NameDuplicationException was genenrated, the previous entity will be removed.

So I modified the code to add an appendix to the name - karid and karxml file id if a NameDuplicationException is generated.

This method was called during processing every karEntries. This is not good, we only need to call it once during generating kar file level (karXML). So I fixed it.

#3 Updated by Jing Tao over 10 years ago

for comment 1:

Ben: it is in You may find the two items there.

#4 Updated by Redmine Admin over 8 years ago

Original Bugzilla ID was 5233

Also available in: Atom PDF