Bug #2412


Unable to Create Kar file from composite

Added by Dan Higgins almost 17 years ago. Updated almost 16 years ago.

Target version:
Start date:
Due date:
% Done:


Estimated time:


A number of problem occur when trying to create a kar file from an existing composite actor in a workflow.

1) If you select a composite and then execute the 'Create Kar from Actor...' menu, the first message says "You cannot create a kar file from an instantiated component. Youmust first make it a class...". Why can't this be done automatically?

2)If you then try the 'Convert to Class' menu item, you get the error
Cannot convert an entity to a class definition while it contains ports with links.' Apparently this means that you must disconnect the links. Again this is a lot of work for the user!

3)After disconnecting the links, a Class actor will appear and if you then 'Create Kar from Actor...' the proper dialog will appear. However, get 'Error Building the KAR file: Cannot create transport KAR: null'

Related issues

Blocks Kepler - Bug #2432: problems saving kars from saved actorsResolvedChad Berkley05/02/2006

Blocks Kepler - Bug #2439: Problem creating KAR from instantiated actorResolvedChad Berkley05/17/2006

Actions #1

Updated by Chad Berkley almost 17 years ago

The reason you cannot create a kar file from an instantiated composite is that the changes to the moml are not saved in the current workflow which makes it impossible to get a handle on the composite's class file (.xml file). Another issue is that if you drag a composite instance to the canvas, then change it, ptii will want you to overwrite the composite's class file. This even happens for TypedCompositeActor.xml. If a user were to do that, all of the composites would change. Unless this behavior is changed, I do not think we can allow users to drag Composite instances.

Unfortunately, that fact also causes the problem in number 2. I'm not sure why you can't create a class from a composite that has linked ports. That seems silly.

All of these problems stem from the fact that ptii handles composites much differently than it handles atomics. Unless we can somehow manage to merge the two concepts, I don't think 1 and 2 can be resolved.

I will work on re-creating #3. This may take some debugging though, since I'm not sure what the exact steps were to cause this error.

Actions #2

Updated by Dan Higgins over 16 years ago

Currently one can create a kar from a composite if the composite was originally created by dragging from the actor tree. However, there is still a problem with selecting a set of actors and then using a menu command to create a composite containing those actors. That menu option has been removed, although it is very useful and we would like to fix it.

Because we can just remove the menu item, changing from 'blocker' to 'critical'

Actions #3

Updated by Dan Higgins almost 16 years ago

Creating a kar file from a composite now works as long as the composite was built from an empty Composite actor and not from the menu where selected actors are automatically put into the composite. [In fact, the menu item for this has been removed.]

I am thus marking this bug as fixed and another bug has been added to get the menu item for building a composite working.
(Dan Higgins)

Actions #4

Updated by Redmine Admin almost 10 years ago

Original Bugzilla ID was 2412


Also available in: Atom PDF