Bug #3188

possible otherEntity and dataTable inconsistances

Added by Callie Bowdish over 14 years ago. Updated over 13 years ago.

eml - general bugs
Target version:
Start date:
Due date:
% Done:


Estimated time:


The otherEntity element contains most of the same elements as the dataTable
element. For some reason the numberOfRecords is only contained in the dataTable
element. I think it would worth thinking about having it available but not
required in the otherEntity element. This way it would be easier to change a
dataTable element to an otherEntity element. It also seems like an
inconsistency. The main difference between the two elements is that a dataTable
requires that that the attributes are described and a otherEntity does not
require that. I think adding the numberOfRecords (not required though, 0 to many) to the otherEntity elements may help with converting dataTable entities to otherEntities when there is problems with listing the attributes.


#1 Updated by Margaret O'Brien almost 14 years ago

numberOfRecords is appropriate for tables, whereas the OtherEntityType is for describing entities that can't be handled by the other types. To find a numberOfRecords element under otherEntity would be confusing. It should not be added to that type only to accommodate incomplete dataTables.

#2 Updated by Matt Jones almost 14 years ago

I agree. We've used otherEntity to hold data objects when we don't yet have an entity/attribute description -- all we know is that it is data. Once we determine that it is a table we should be moving it to the dataTable entity type. Unless someone posts a rationale here for keeping this bug open, I suggest it be closed as 'won't fix'.

#3 Updated by Margaret O'Brien over 13 years ago

bug resolved, changed to WONTFIX

#4 Updated by Redmine Admin over 9 years ago

Original Bugzilla ID was 3188

Also available in: Atom PDF